Sign up ×
Cognitive Sciences Stack Exchange is a question and answer site for practitioners, researchers, and students in cognitive science, psychology, neuroscience, and psychiatry. It's 100% free, no registration required.

Homosexuals are oft criticized for their sexuality to which they would say they are just not attracted to the member of the opposite sex and that it's the other way round.

So, is this attraction to member's of the same-sex a (by-birth) psychological illness (that could be treated), a natural disposition, or just voluntary choice?

Or maybe something else?

share|improve this question
Just because someone is born with an unusual trait (with its own pros and cons) doesn't mean it's an illness - you wouldn't say that being short is an illness, even though it prevents you from reaching the apples in the tree. – user6682 Oct 21 '14 at 10:03

2 Answers 2

Freud (1905) believed that every human was innately bisexual, and that monosexuality (i.e. hetero- or homosexuality) is a result of internal and external influences during psychological maturation.

Currently, the question of a biological, e.g. genetic or uterine, cause of non-heterosexual sexual orientation is still a subject of research and has not yet led to any conclusive results. Until that question has been answered with some level of certainy, we simply do not know whether homosexuality is a natural variety of sexuality or a deviation from an inborn disposition through influences after birth. (Wikipedia summarizes the research well:

What you must differentiate is homosexual behavior, which can appear in heterosexual individuals such as experimenting adolescents or prisoners, and homosexuality, which is a preference for same-sex partners, which might not show up in behavior at all. Historically, many homosexuals led heterosexual lives, marrying, mating with and procreating with opposite-sex partners, despite a contrary sexual preference.

  • Freud, S. (1905). Drei Abhandlungen zur Sexualtheorie. Leipzig: Deuticke.
share|improve this answer
Freud was wrong about nearly everything no one cites him anyone – user3832 Feb 2 '14 at 2:53
I agree with user3832. Freud is mentioned in textbooks because of his contributions to the Cognitive Sciences while it was in its infancy, not because of the validity of his theories. So I'm sure of the point of putting that at the top of your answer, when it's more of a curious footnote. – fredsbend Jul 14 at 19:20
I arranged my answer in chronological order, as is the convention in scientific overviews. Many of Freud's contributions still stand today, such as the unconscious, which neuropsychologists study today, or many of the psychological defense mechanisms, which have been shown to exist, or transference and countertransference, a concept that even cognitive behavioral therapists work with nowadays. You shouldn't blindly repeat the opinions of the ignorant, but actually study the reception of psychoanalysis today. – what Jul 15 at 6:12

It never should have been considered an illness. Homosexuality was at one time viewed as a psychological illness from DSM-I in 1952 to the 7th printing of DSM-II in 1974. Psychologist corrected themselves and it is no longer viewed as an illness.

Homosexuality can happen as a result of scarcity and sexual drive. (as such often happens in prisons) It can also happen as a single sexual desire; those having no desire to have sex with the opposite gender. Most of the time it is present from birth but things can happen in someones life to cause them to have homosexual desires.

All attempts to "treat" homosexuality have failed as conversion therapy works only for those who are extremely religiously motivated and causes harm to those individuals. Abstinence works for both homosexuals and hetrosexuals who find conflict with their sexuality but autonomic functions eventually force the body to be somewhat sexual.

share|improve this answer
This is an appeal to authority, not an answer to the question. – fredsbend Jul 14 at 19:22
"Homosexuality can happen as a result of scarcity and sexual drive." No. Homosexual sex is not the same thing as homosexuality. Homosexuality is an orientation. Sex is a behavior. Heterosexuals can and do under certain circumstances engage in homosexual sex, just as homosexuals can and do under certain circumstances engage in heterosexual sex. – Lee Woofenden Jul 16 at 17:12

Your Answer


By posting your answer, you agree to the privacy policy and terms of service.

Not the answer you're looking for? Browse other questions tagged or ask your own question.